Abstract

Excerpted From: Neena Albarus, An Overview of the Ongoing Legacies of Colonialism in Contemporary Legal Systems in the Black Diaspora, 23 Berkeley Journal of African-American Law & Policy 15 (2023) (69 Footnotes) (Full Document)

The Black Diaspora comprises a global community of people of African descent who have been separated from their ancestral homelands due to slavery, colonialism, and economic exploitation. The lasting impact of colonialism is evident in the legal systems and policies of many countries in the Black Diaspora, which have influenced land ownership, property rights, natural resource extraction, and criminal justice systems. Legal systems are a process for interpreting and enforcing law. This process involves various institutions, including courts, law enforcement agencies, and legal professionals, who work together to interpret and apply the law to specific situations. To ensure the practical application of law is effective, it is important to understand the cultural perspective that is implicitly embedded in legal doctrine. In the Black Diaspora, the impact of colonialism on legal systems has been significant, as legal systems have historically been used to enforce systems of racial hierarchy and oppression. The imposition of European-based laws and institutions by colonial forces often suppressed local legal traditions and perpetuated land and economic inequality, environmental degradation, and systemic biases against minority communities. Today, many countries in the Black Diaspora continue to confront these legacies of colonialism, which affect the lives of millions of people across the world.

This perspective paper aims to explore how these legacies have influenced the legal systems and policies of countries in the Black Diaspora, with a particular focus on the US, Caribbean, Latin America, and other regions. Through this examination, the paper intends to contribute to ongoing efforts to address the challenges faced by the Black Diaspora and gain a deeper understanding of the dynamics of colonialism and the rule of law. By gaining a deeper understanding of the cultural perspective that underlies legal doctrine and promoting a more inclusive and equitable legal profession, we can work towards a legal system that is more responsive to the needs and concerns of marginalized communities.

[. . .]

The impact of colonialism on legal systems in the Black Diaspora has been significant and continues to affect the lives of millions of people today. The imposition of European-based laws and institutions by colonial forces often suppressed local legal traditions and perpetuated systems of racial hierarchy and oppression, leading to unequal access to resources, environmental degradation, and systemic biases against minority communities. There is often a lack of political will to address the root causes of crime, such as poverty, inequality, and social exclusion. Instead, policies focus on punishment and repression, leading to the further marginalization of Black communities. In some cases, the state has even been complicit in the perpetuation of violence against Black people, as in the case of police brutality and extrajudicial killings. Moreover, the ongoing legacies of colonialism have also resulted in the erasure and marginalization of traditional legal systems and customary law in many Black Diaspora communities. This has led to a lack of recognition and protection for the rights and interests of Indigenous peoples and other marginalized groups, as their legal systems are often ignored or subordinated to the colonial legal framework.

To address these issues, there is a need to critically examine the colonial legal systems and their legacy, as well as to advocate for decolonization and justice. This requires a comprehensive understanding of the complex relationship between colonialism and post-colonial development, as well as a recognition of the importance of traditional legal systems and customary law in many Black Diaspora communities. A multifaceted approach to addressing these laws includes promoting greater diversity and inclusion within the legal profession, advocating for less punitive laws, prioritizing collective safety and equity in law, and adopting restorative justice models. One critical aspect of decolonizing our legal systems is recognizing the ways in which colonial-era laws and policies continue to negatively affect marginalized communities in the Black Diaspora. This includes acknowledging the historical context in which these laws were created and understanding the ways in which they perpetuate systemic inequality and discrimination. Promoting greater diversity and inclusion within the legal profession is another crucial step towards decolonization. This involves increasing the representation of Black lawyers and judges in the courts, which can help ensure that legal systems and policies are more responsive to the needs and concerns of the Black community. Advocating for less punitive laws and prioritizing more rehabilitative approaches to justice is also essential to decolonizing our legal systems. This includes moving away from individualistic interventions and instead prioritizing collective safety and equity in law. Adopting restorative justice models can also facilitate the healing process, particularly by preserving the dignity of Black individuals in the legal system given the sordid history of colonialism. Ultimately, decolonizing our legal systems requires a multifaceted and intersectional approach that prioritizes the needs and concerns of marginalized communities in the Black Diaspora. By taking meaningful steps towards greater diversity and inclusion, less punitive laws, and restorative justice models, we can work towards a more just and equitable legal system that serves all members of society.

PhD Student, UC Berkeley School of Social Welfare; MSW, The University of the West Indies, Mona, Jamaica.